The Santa Clause
The saccharin music chirping through retail stores everywhere today confirms it: Christmas season is here in force. Actually, it seems to come earlier every year as evidenced by the displays in stores, but that's been well covered. I actually like Christmas quite a bit. True, if I never hear “Jingle Bell Rock” again in my life it'll be too soon, but I do enjoy the mass efforts to be a little nicer, a little more considerate, and a little more thankful.
T
here is one part of Christmas though, that rankles me to no end, and that is Santa Claus. I don't know how that greybeard loon became such a holiday fixture, but it wasn't with my blessing. And my distaste has nothing to do with the true meaning of Christmas. I don't give a damn about the true meaning of Christmas, and neither does anyone else, or else he or she would celebrate it in November or July or whenever the latest revision of Jesus' birthday currently falls. My issue with Santa Claus is the dishonesty.
Everyone knows there is no Santa Claus. This is not like life after death, or aliens, where you can't prove a negative. EVERYONE knows. No only do we know there is no Santa Claus, but we also know that all those presents got under the tree, because adults put them there. And they weren't delivered in a sled but in a Ford. The closest thing to truth in the whole tale is that the toys are made by little unpaid workers. So for someone to look in a kid's eyes and boldly tell them that there is a fat man with a beard, who lives in the North Pole – where there is no land – and makes toys and gives them to all the good girls and boys – which is bribery pure and simple – and who watches all the kids and knows who's been naughty or nice – HOLY CRAP WHAT THE HELL KIND OF STORY IS THIS? I bet if you took a poll of every parent in the world and asked, “Is it important that your kids are totally honest with you?” they would all, to a man and woman, answer yes. Yet it's no problem to sell them a fairy tale whose offenses against morality are trumped only by those against physics.
Just as people bemoan the lost meaning of Christmas, Santa Claus has a noble heritage degraded into farce. The main inspiration seems to be the 4th century Saint Nicholas of Myra, who was noted for his generous gifts to the poor and in particular for giving a dowry to three sisters so they could get married and avoid a life of prostitution. Somehow we've gone from that noble philanthropist to an overweight flying watchdog who bribes children to behave well. As usual, the terrestrial explanation is so much more grand.
A friend of mine who harped at length about the importance of honesty, even in friendly games of Wii Baseball, conceded without shame that she planned to tell her kids about Santa Clause. When I pointed out here obvious hypocrisy she said, “But I remember how magical Santa was for me, and I want my kids to have that too.”
First off, no you don't remember. The fallibility of memory has been proven many times over, and what you're really “remembering” is the way your present 'you' feels about the idea of Santa, and maybe combining that with some speculation on the joy of of having little rugrats of your own to share the tale with. The odds that you actually remember how you felt, as a five year old, thinking about Santa, are miniscule. I think it's a pretty good bet that any joy and wonder you did feel were not because of Santa, but the MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF PRESENTS you were about to receive. It doesn't matter if it's a jolly man in a red suit, a jolly green giant, or a green goblin; if he's bringing you a Nintendo you'll feel pretty magical.
On occasion you'll hear an outcry because some random adult disabused a child of this foolish belief (I have an article up right now about a substitute teacher fired for telling a classroom of seven year-olds there was no Santa Claus. The outcry was severe). People will say it's the parents' right to raise their kids how they want, but that argument never held water for me. If parents wanted to raise their kids to be filthy little racists, is that their right? I certainly hope not, and we would all hope, in that situation, for an honest teacher. If it's the parents' right to lie to their kids, it's certainly a teacher's right to tell them the truth.
(As a side not, my wonderful mother, a Montessori teacher who never bothered her kids with this fairy tale, accidentally yet frequently let slip to her students the truth of Santa's non-existence, even to kids as old as nine. Nine!)
I never advocate a fantasy over reality, part because of the dishonesty, but also because, as with the truth behind the real Saint Nick, reality is always so much more grand, so much more impressive. People talk about the magic of Santa Claus, but how does that compare to the love of your family? Parents who will take the time to find the right present for you, spending money they might not even have, because they want to see the joy on your face Christmas morning? And if you've transgressed a time or two over the last year, well...you're still their beloved child. Next to that, the 'magic' of Santa Claus is weak stuff indeed.








